Should Your School Allow Facebook Wall Posts From Fans
When you sign up for a Fan Page with Facebook.com, you have a number of options in regards to who can and can not contribute to your Page. Many schools have trouble determining what settings should be used here and whether or not they want to allows their Fans to directly contribute to their school’s Facebook Page. Based on the email below, this is obviously an issue some schools are dealing with.
I notice that some schools have Facebook pages that do not allow for wall posts while others do. I wonder what your perspective is on schools allowing for wall posts versus not.
Any tips you can share, I’d really appreciate it!!
Kristin Harrison
My response here is relatively simple: The ultimate goal for your school should be to open up the permissions as much as possible, so that eventually you are allowing your Fans to post new content, comment, and leave feedback on your school’s Facebook Fan Page.
In case you are unfamiliar with Facebook Fan Page permissions, check out the graphic below.

To find these settings on your school’s Facebook Fan Page, simply log into Facebook, navigate to your Page, and then click the “Edit Page” link found directly underneath your school’s logo/picture. From there, you will see an area called “Wall Settings.” Click the “Edit” link under that section and then you will see the “Wall Setting” options shown above.
As you can see, you have the choice of allowing “Posts by Page and Fans” or of allowing “Only Posts by Page.” (For those who don’t know, YOU are the Page. So, if you choose to allow posts only by the Page, that means that only you (and other Page administrators) will be allowed to post new content to your school’s Facebook Fan Page).
Under the sub-heading titled “Fan Permissions” you will also note that you can give your Fans permission to write or post on your Page, as well as permission to post photos, videos or outside links. Leaving these boxes checked gives your Fans permission to post just about anything they want. Unchecking one or more of these boxes removes your Fans from being allowed to post that particular kind of content.
The problem many schools have when it comes to these settings is that they are simply nervous (or even afraid) about what kind of content/remarks their Fans will leave if they give them permission to post whatever they want. For many schools, this is a justified concern.
That said, if you work in a school that is currently having problems of some kind that could result in outrageous negative feedback from the community, then I think it is perfectly fine to block off access to your Fans and only allow new content to be posted by you and other Fan Page administrators. However, this should not be something that you do forever. The ultimate goal should be to start with your Page permissions blocked off, but then to eventually lift those permissions so that slowly, over time, you give your Fans more and more rights on your Page.
When you block your Fans from posting on your Page, you are essentially blocking them from giving you any kind of feedback. Essentially, you have turned your Facebook Fan Page into a one-way communication channel, with you pumping out the information and your Fans taking it in – unable to respond, even if they wanted to. This, as far as I am concerned, is not social media… and using your Facebook Fan Page in this way may work for a while, but it is far from effective.
You see, the great part about allowing your Fans to leave comments and contribute to your school’s Fan Page is that:
First of all, you get feedback on what the parents, teachers, students, staff, and community members liked or did not like about certain events or activities in your school/district. This can be a bit scary at times, but it is the best way to learn and grow from an administration standpoint. Every time you do something new or exciting in your school you can make a post about it on Facebook and almost instantly get feedback as to what your community liked, disliked, or would like you to do next time you conduct a similar event. From a marketing and education standpoint, this is vital information for any school to have.
Secondly, opening up the permissions on your Facebook Fan Page actually causes you to do less work, because your Fans will be helping you to build the content of your Facebook Page for you. I know that from my talks with several schools around the world, time is an important factor in their resistance to use social media sites like Facebook and Twitter. They think that social media use in their school will take too much time – something that they feel they just don’t have very much to give away. But the truth is, posting new content to Facebook and Twitter takes just minutes per day, and when you allow your parents, teachers and students to directly add new content to your school’s Page, it creates even less work that you have to do yourself. After a while, your Page may become almost self-sufficient, with the community around your school doing 90% of the work and you chiming in just once a day to moderate comments and make new and important updates.
Finally, the biggest advantage to allowing your Fans to contribute to your Page is that each time someone comments on your Page, a notice is then automatically posted on that person’s individual Profile, notifying his or her friends that they just made a comment on your school’s Facebook Fan Page. This is huge because this is how you get more and more people to know about your school. When someone leaves a comment on your school’s Page, his or her friends are notified about it, and many of them will be inclined to navigate back to your school’s pPage, become a fan, or contribute to the Page themselves. As a marketing tool, this is incredibly powerful and something that should be encouraged if possible – not something that should be restricted.
So you see, it is okay to block off your Fans from posting comments and new content to your school’s Facebook Fan Page, but the ultimate goal should be to open up those permissions as much as possible so as to get immediate feedback, automatically grow your Page, and increase your school’s awareness amongst your community’s Facebook users. When you can… and when you feel comfortable doing it, I encourage you to open up those permissions as much as possible.
Stop viewing your Facebook Fan Page as a one-way communication channel between your school and the neighboring community… and start seeing it as an opportunity to create an army of raving Fans!
Related Articles
6 Responses to “Should Your School Allow Facebook Wall Posts From Fans”
Leave a Reply




kknock on April 7th, 2010
The problem isn’t users posting to a school’s page. It’s advertisers and political action groups posting to the page. There is a big difference in allowing someone to comment on a school’s story and allowing them to post an original story that all fans will see.
delainanicole on April 7th, 2010
I have 2 followup questions.
I don’t mind leaving our fan page open for parents and employees to add content. However, people who have created personal profiles in the name of organizations (instead of creating fan pages for those organizations) have been adding their own announcements and plugs to our page wall. (See http://www.facebook.com/TempeElementary)
Do I delete these? They just come across as so spammy and I don’t want our fans to be turned off by these filling up the wall.
Also, what are your thoughts on the default view settings for fan walls? There are the three options: Show content posted by admin only, show content posted by admin and fans, or show content from fans only. A lot of schools/districts I’ve seen have it set to show only admin content. So far, I’ve opted to show both fans and admin. What do you think?
Brendan Schneider on April 8th, 2010
Darren,
You are right on!! The purpose of social media is engagement and limiting access to your Facebook Fan Page wall is missing the point of social media.
A couple of additional thoughts:
1. In my work with admissions at independent schools I have found that the positive posts or interactions by our schools Facebook Fans is invaluable. The authenticity of the their words and their stories is worth more then all of the traditional advertising I can do in terms of having a family look at my school.
2. The thought that one can control social media is an illusion and if someone is going to post something negative about your school they will find a place to do it. If you do not allow them to comment on your Facebook Fan Page then you are missing a huge opportunity to respond to the criticism on your terms and by delivering your message.
Keep up the good work!
Thanks,
Brendan
Steve & Beneta on May 27th, 2010
Hey Friends:
Thanks for the kudos and Brenden you are so right that “one can control social media is an illusion”! The best way to approach the critics is to deal with it in a positive manner in full view of everyone! This is your opportunity to get “Your Message” out in the correct way and put a positive spin on it.
Delaina:
I would allow content from admin and fans. This is all part of “Transparency” and if you aren’t open and up front with your community they aren’t going to see the value in your page and then “STOP FOLLOWING YOU”. Then all your work has been for nothing. In the few rare cases where a person is being malicious, simply report them to Facebook and delete their comments. Your community is smart enough to distinguish between constructive criticism and malicious name bashing! Hope this helps.
Steve Nelson
Social Media School